As New York and other states gird for the possibility of a shortage of ventilators, ethicists wonder if a lottery will be the fairest option
for allocating ventilators in a pandemic, they coalesced around a clear principle: Scarce resources should go to the person most likely to be saved. But they had to contemplate another, tougher, situation: What if a number of patients were equally likely to benefit?The specter of such extreme rationing – a large number of critically ill patients confronting a finite supply of life-saving machinery – was grim but theoretical when debated by the philosophically minded panel.
Among hospitals around the country, there are widely accepted basic ethical principles on establishing priorities for health treatment, and dozens of bioethics and pandemic planning reports that stress directing scarce resources to patients likely to benefit. But there’s no uniform, national framework for emergency rooms across the country to turn to in crisis. Only a few states have worked out their own guidelines, with hard-hit New York and Washington state among them.
Nonetheless, public-health experts said many hospitals have inadequate guidance – legal or ethical – to develop protocols on who gets priority. The New York report concluded that when multiple patients are equally likely to recover, but there are limited resources to help them, hospitals “utilize ‘random selection’ methods.”
Indeed, Betsy McCaughey, a historian turned conservative health policy commentator who was one of the Obamacare critics associated with the false “death panel” attacks, is blaming any eventual coronavirus-related rationing on Gov. Andrew Cuomo’s mismanagement. In one New York Post article, she referred to ethics experts as “triage officers” and added, “In truth, a death officer. Let's not sugarcoat it.
日本 最新ニュース, 日本 見出し
Similar News:他のニュース ソースから収集した、これに似たニュース記事を読むこともできます。
A 'Communication Issue' Means The UK Hasn’t Been Working With The EU To Get More VentilatorsIn severe cases of the coronavirus, hospitals use ventilators to help people breathe.
続きを読む »
Trump claims U.S. states don't need the amount of ventilators they're asking for: 'I don't believe you need 40,000 or 30,000''You know, at a major hospital sometimes they'll have two ventilators,' Trump said. 'All of a sudden they're saying, 'Can we order 30,000 ventilators?''
続きを読む »
Trump Is Haggling Over Ventilator Prices While Coronavirus Patients DieThe Trump administration is reportedly worried about ordering too many ventilators, as hospitals face grave shortages
続きを読む »
One ventilator, two patients: New York hospitals shift to crisis modeAt least one New York hospital has begun putting two patients on a single ventilator machine, an experimental crisis-mode protocol some doctors worry is too risky but others deemed necessary as the coronavirus outbreak strains medical resources.
続きを読む »
Animal Hospitals, Vets And Zoos Donate Use Of Ventilators To Treat Coronavirus PatientsThe critically needed equipment is being offered to hospitals around the country as they prepare for more COVID-19 cases.
続きを読む »
'On-the-job emergency training': Hospitals may run low on staff to run ventilators for coronavirus patientsThe desperate need for ventilators for coronavirus patients is only part of the problem: There aren't enough trained workers to run them.
続きを読む »